Skip to content
Home » Five Points and Collect Pond: The Real Story

Five Points and Collect Pond: The Real Story

Five Points and Collect Pond: The Real Story

The Five Points is one of the most famous neighborhoods in New York history, and one of the most mythologized. A hit film turned it into a legend of gang warfare. The real story is more interesting: it begins with a pond, a bad building site, and some of the poorest newcomers in America.

Collect Pond

In colonial New York, a large freshwater pond called Collect Pond covered much of what is now Foley Square and Chinatown. The city filled it in during the early nineteenth century, but the ground stayed wet and unstable. Houses built on it sank and shifted, rents fell, and the area became home to people with nowhere else to go.

The Five Points

The neighborhood took its name from the five-way intersection where Anthony, Cross, and Orange Streets met (today’s Worth, Mosco, and Baxter Streets). By the mid-1800s it was crowded with Irish and other immigrants living in run-down buildings, and it gained a fearsome reputation in newspapers and reformers’ reports. The original Five Points buildings are long gone, replaced by later construction, parks, and civic buildings, including Columbus Park, which now covers part of the old neighborhood.

Myth vs. reality

The 2002 film Gangs of New York made the Five Points world-famous, but it dramatized and compressed decades of history. Real Five Points gangs existed, but so did churches, schools, missions, and reformers, and so did ordinary families trying to get by. The neighborhood’s story is really the story of how New York handled poverty, immigration, and corruption, and the reforms that followed.

FAQ

  • Where was the Five Points? Around today’s Columbus Park and Foley Square in Lower Manhattan, where Worth, Baxter, and Mosco Streets meet.
  • What happened to Collect Pond? It was filled in during the early 1800s; the unstable filled ground helped create the crowded, run-down Five Points neighborhood.
  • Is Gangs of New York historically accurate? It captures the atmosphere of the era but heavily dramatizes real events and people, the true story is more complex.

Walk this history: the Five Points streets are on the route of our Five Points, Chinatown & Little Italy Walking Tour, a private walking tour led by historians and lifelong locals. Private tours run daily on request. $150 for one hour / $300 for two hours per group. To book, visit leshp.org or call (347) 465-7767.

More Lower East Side history